La Otra Conquista
by Sasha Stone
La Otra Conquista tells the story of the Spanish conquest of the
Americas, but more importantly, the high price the Aztec culture paid,
both spirtitually and materialistically, at the hands of the Spanish.
Writer/director Salvador Corrasco thought it was time to tell the other
side of the story, the ones most of us didn't learn about in high school.
The film opens on the Aztec capital of Tenochtitlán in 1520 following
the Spanish conquest. Topiltzin (Damian Delgado), an Aztec picture-writer,
is captured by the Spaniards during a raid of a human sacrifice ceremony.
Topiltzin, the illigitimate son of Emperor Moctezuma, is deemed a savage
who is then brought to Hernando Cortez for execution. But because Cortes
(and many Spanish leaders like him) has taken Emperor Moctezuma's daughter
Tecuichpo (Elpidia Carrillo) as mistress, and has subsequently fallen
in love with her, the emperor is convinced to let Topilztin live.
However, to live means to change his name to Tomas, convert to Christianity,
abandon his native language and speak Spanish, and survive a brutal
punishment - thirty lashings with a whip and chain, and a torch set
to the bottoms of his feet while a statue of the Virgin Mary looks on.
Tomas/Topiltzin is forced into the arms of the Virgin Mary at every
turn. The strangely sad, judgmental, serene statue has so much screen
time that she is as vivid and alive as the characters in the film. Her
appearance is perhaps one of the most effective elements of La Otra
Conquista when considering Mexico today. A culture continually associated
with Catholicism has its roots elsewhere. Yet, because the film is ultimately
in support of the belief in god (that faith is the universal part),
it doesn't matter what face it's wearing, Mexico did not reject the
film's ideas, quite the opposite in fact. The film became wildly popular
in Mexico during its release in 1999, earning $2 million at the box
office. Of course, that seems a paltry sum by our standards, but for
Mexico, it's huge.
Its U.S. release is being closely watched. Much money was invested
in the publicity, which didn't target Latino groups specifically, but
rather attempted to reach a broader audience, from art houses to the
general public. How will it fare with an audience who shells out hundreds
of millions for Julia Roberts' smile?
Indeed, word of mouth is spreading fast, particularly for Latinos and
art house filmgoers. What remains to be seen is whether a mass audience
can identify with or embrace this brand of filmmaking - spare and symbolic,
closer to magic realism than to traditionally historical dramas. The
last film that cross-connected many in and out of the Latino community
was Like Water for Chocolate. Will La Ostra Conquista
enjoy the same worldwide success?
story is a triumph of the human spirit, though it is not as romantic
as Like Water for Chocolate, which was the film's draw. It also
doesn't have a popular novel backing it up. In fact, it's more along
the lines of Spielberg's Schindler's List - at once moving and
painful to watch.
However, one thing it does share with Like Water for Chocolate
is its absolute loveliness. In one of the more astonishing feature film
debuts in recent memory, Carrasco has filled every frame with beautiful,
agonizing realism that reflects both our common knowledge of history
as well as his vibrant imagination. He gets much help from Samuel Zyman's
score and his production designer (and wife) Andrea Sanderson, but clearly,
Carrasco is the standout here.
One can only hope he is not sucked up, chewed vigorously and spit out
by the Hollywood machine, and given silly, badly written films to direct.
Carrasco ought to emerge as one of the world's best directors, taking
his place alongside such uncompromising giants as Abbas Kiarostami,
Martin Scorsese, and Akira Kurosawa, rather than being given far too
much rein, like Luc Besson or Robert Rodriguez.
took Carrasco, and partner Alvaro Domingo (son of executive producer,
Placido) nearly ten years to realize their dream of making La Otra
Conquista, a devotion that is evident in nearly every well-conceived
frame of the film. This clearly wasn't hashed out in five minutes in
some Hollywood pitchfest; this is the real deal, one of those films
that ends up taking a place in cinema history and remaining there, refusing
to be forgotten, dated or ineffectual.
La Otra Conquista gives a face and a name to the mysterious
world of the Aztecs. Though we now know that the beauty and spirit endure,
we must remember just how high a price the Aztecs paid, and in some
ways, how the Mexican people are still paying for their loss.
La Otra Conquista, written, directed and edited by Salvador
Corrasco, produced by Alvaro Domingo, starring Damián Delgado, José
Carlos Rodríguez, Elpidia Carrillo, Iñaki Aierra, Parents Warning: graphic
violence, sex and nudity